Uncovering Fossils and Gemstones at the Hicksville Gregory Museum

Please do your best to limit your travels around New York during this time. If you decide to travel, please check the status of the places you are going. Some places around the state are temporarily closed or have changed their hours We will not be updating individual articles to note these changes. Stay safe and wear a mask!

Located along the Long Island Railroad, Hicksville, New York is a sleepy suburb of New York City that’s probably best known as the childhood hometown of Billy Joel. However, for those that find themselves in the area, there is a great reason to not skip over this town: the Hicksville Gregory Museum.

The Hicksville Gregory Museum is located within the Heitz Place Courthouse which dates back to 1895 and is on the National Historic Register. Inside this historic structure is one of the most unique local museums I’ve come across in my travels.

Heitz Place Courthouse in Hicksville NY
The Heitz Place Courthouse in Hicksville is now home to the Hicksville Gregory Museum.

What makes this museum so special is its amazing collection of fossils, rocks, and minerals.

Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. We will make a small commission from these links if you order something at no additional cost to you.

Most of this collection is housed in one large room on the building’s main floor. Here you’ll find cabinets lining the walls of the room and filled to the brim will all manner of specimens. It’s really amazing how many pieces they have fit into this room.

However, despite being quite full, the items aren’t cluttered and it’s easy, though a bit overwhelming, to go through each cabinet and look through all the items on display.

Hadrosaur Dinosaur fossil at the Hicksville Gregory Museum on Long Island New York
The Hadrosaur fossil might be a replica, but it makes for a great introduction to the museum.

For me, the highlight of the museum was the many dinosaur fossils, as well as fossils of other plants and animals. Most of these are authentic fossils, though the large Hadrosaur skull in the case right inside the museum’s entrance is a replica of a fossil on display at the Royal Ontario Museum in Toronto.

Most of the dinosaur, planet, and other animal fossils on display are smaller things like teeth, eggs, footprints, or the imprints of smaller animals. There are, however, some larger ones, including a very cool mastodon tusk and a large collection of eggs.

It’s rare to see so many great and authentic fossils on display in one place, especially at a smaller museum such as this one.

Fossilized dinosaur eggs at the Hicksville Gregory Museum in Hicksville New York
A collection of fossilized dinosaur eggs.

This main room is also home to many rocks and minerals from around the world.

Many of these rocks are next to excellent signage that tells you a bit more about the rock and where it was found. I especially enjoyed the places where they had a polished gemstone sitting next to a natural rock of the same variety.

In addition to rocks from around the world, there was also a section that talked about the geology of Long Island. While I found this section to be well done, I’d imagine those that live in the area would find it especially interesting.

Gemstones at the Hicksville Gregory Museum in Nassau County NY
There is a large collection of rocks and gemstones in the museum.

In addition to the main room, there is also a hallway that features some great displays.

Here you’ll find a collection of hundreds of butterflies and moths that have been collected from around the world. These specimens are mounted in containers and organized by the region of the world they are from.

I found it very interesting to compare and contrast these insects that can be found all over the earth.

Butterflies on display at the Hicksville Gregory Museum in Hicksville New York
A small portion of the museum’s butterfly and moth collection.

There is also a fantastic display case filled with fluorescent minerals. While they look nice under normal lighting, ask someone that works at the Hicksville Gregory Museum to turn off the lights to get the full effect. I was honestly pretty amazed at how unique and beautiful these minerals were under a black light.

The final section of the museum is located inside what was the courthouse’s jail.

In this section of the museum, you’ll find a nice collection of local artifacts that help tell the story of Hicksville from its earliest days through more recent years. This area functions much like a local historical society and offers a great glimpse into the region’s history.

Jail Cell in the Heitz Place Courthouse in Hicksville New York
There is a diorama set up in the courthouse’s one remaining jail cell.

In the adjacent room, you’ll find the courthouse’s only remaining jail cell. There are several mannequins set up inside the cell that offers a nice look at what it was like to spend time in a small-town jail.

Overall, the Hicksville Gregory Museum is a great stop in Nassau County, New York. Even though the museum itself isn’t large, they pack a lot of interesting artifacts into a small space. Not only are the local history exhibits are interesting, but this is definitely a spot that those who love fossils and geology won’t want to miss during their time on Long Island.

Looking for more places to visit nearby? Check out the American Airpower Museum, Keg and Lantern Brewing, Fifth Hammer Brewing, and the National Museum of the American Indian.


Hicksville Gregory Museum

Hours: Tuesday-Friday: 9:30a-4:30p
Saturday-Sunday: 1p-5p

Cost: Adults: $5, Kids: $3

Website: GregoryMuseum.org

Address: 1 Heitz Place
Hicksville, NY 11801

Review of the Hicksville Gregory Museum in Hicksville New York



More nearby places worth exploring

Find more things to do on Long Island!

Leave a Comment